Almost every week, someone calls me and says, “My website just isn’t helping me. You came recommended. Can you help?”

Most marketers and web developers jump straight to a new website, because that’s what they sell. I recommend a new site only about a third of the time. Before anyone talks about rebuilding, I start with a quick consultation.

First question: what makes you think your site isn’t working?

Sometimes the site really is down. More often, it’s live, it looks fine, and it just isn’t showing up in search or bringing you leads.

Want to talk through this on the phone now? Give me a call.

Where I look

I check three places:

  1. Your website itself. I figure out what platform it’s built on and run a Lighthouse audit, a free Google tool that flags major speed, accessibility, and SEO problems. I also ask whether you’re sure your contact forms and links actually work.
  2. Semrush. This SEO tool shows me where you rank today and how that has changed over time. I can usually see when your site launched and when any major changes happened.
  3. Google Search Console and Google Analytics. I’ll ask for access if you have them. Search Console is Google’s own tool for submitting your sitemap, seeing how you rank, and troubleshooting SEO problems. If a developer built your site and never set it up, that’s a huge red flag.

From there, most sites land in one of three places.

  1. Your site is performing well. We need to look deeper.

    You might already be at the top of search for your name, your services, and your area.

  2. Your site is in good shape. It needs tweaks and a consistent strategy.

    Your site is built well on a solid platform, and the forms and links work.

  3. Yes, you need a new site.

    Your site doesn’t rank for many keywords, isn't indexable at all, or needs a major redesign to help customers reach you.

1. Your site is performing well. We need to look deeper.

You might already be at the top of search for your name, your services, and your area. This happens more often than you’d think. If that’s you, I won’t recommend a new site or major changes without careful planning, because we don’t want to break what’s working. Instead, I’ll dig into a few questions:

  • Is your site speaking to the customers or supporters you actually want? Does it give them useful information and a clear way to contact you?
  • Do your contact forms work? What about your click-to-call buttons? You wouldn’t believe how often those are broken.
  • What happens after a lead comes in? Does your team follow up, and what does that process look like?

The fixes here tend to be either very simple or very involved. Either way, we start working toward a solution right away.

2. Your site is in good shape. It needs tweaks and a consistent strategy.

This is a common spot. Your site is built well on a solid platform, and the forms and links work. You rank for a few keywords, but not enough to feel like your website is growing your organization. We wouldn’t recommend a new site here. Instead, we:

  • Get access to your site’s back end to make sure everything is healthy. On WordPress especially, even a couple of months of missed updates can start to hurt.
  • Review the SEO basics: page titles, meta descriptions, content, and load time.
  • When you’re ready, scope a one-time project to fix what we found, plus a maintenance plan so the problems don’t come back.

If you’re here, you probably don’t need a new site. You need updates and someone dedicated to keeping it working.

3. Yes, you need a new site.

If your site doesn’t rank for anything, needs a major redesign to help customers reach you, or runs on a platform that’s known to cause problems (looking at you, Wix, and the aging or patched-together WordPress build), a new site may be the right call.

A new site, built right, gives you:

  • Fundamentals that work from day one. SEO best practices are in place, forms work, and we set up a clear process for handling every lead and donation that comes in.
  • A site that’s fast and modern. It looks great, loads fast, meets modern standards, and is accessible to your whole audience. We build on several platforms and will pick what’s right for you.
  • A team that sticks around. We maintain the site, fix issues, and keep it current.

You might not need a new site. We’ll tell you honestly.

Our job is to help your business or nonprofit grow, and your website is one of the best tools for that. We’re not here just to sell you a new one.

Every site we adjust in any way will be built to perform well for SEO and AI search, load fast, and grow your organization.

While we're based in Blacksburg, Virginia, we can assist customers throughout the United States. We deeply understand the needs of modern website development, including accessibility and the changing world of search. We're happy to work remote and find a solution that fits your needs.

If you’d like to understand where your website stands and what to do next, reach out.

Get in touch

Get in touch

Simply reach out to us and we'll have this consultation with you, discussing your actual site and the goals of your organization.